A leadership skills assessment belongs on every people team’s agenda, because each leader is directly responsible for how their team performs. But where do you start, which skills should you check, and which tools should you use? Here are some practical paths.
Leaders play a central role in any company. They assign work, track project progress, motivate people, answer questions, and act as the bridge between the team and senior management.
At many companies, they also take part in hiring, give feedback to their direct reports, and suggest process improvements. Because they hold a strategic position, they need to be closely aligned with what the company expects.
How to choose a leader
Many companies promote from within and appoint a new leader for a department. The people who stand out most, with the most experience and expertise, often end up in the role.
Sometimes a person becomes a leader because they grew with the company from the early days and earned the position on merit. After all, they hold valuable knowledge about an area they have followed for a long time.
In other cases, the company hires externally. The new leader goes through stages that range from resume screening to technical and behavioral assessments and, above all, a culture fit interview.
Since leaders pass the company culture on to everyone on the team, from new hires to long-time employees, they need a wide range of skills and competencies.
Which leadership skills to assess
The most important skills depend on the company. At startups building technology products, such as apps and business software, a leader also needs to know the languages and frameworks the team uses.
In short, technical skills vary the most from company to company, while the soft skills expected from a leader are fairly similar everywhere. These are the most requested.
Communication and interpersonal skills
Clear communication saves time, limits damage, and prevents misunderstandings. A leader must communicate well, listen, and explain the next steps of each task. Interpersonal skills, in turn, give them the diplomacy to handle tough moments and encourage each person to do their best work.
Decision making and problem solving
Leaders get the autonomy to make decisions and solve problems every day. It makes little sense for them to check with their manager every time they face a choice between option A and option B. One essential skill is having enough information and confidence to decide well without stalling the team’s work.
Leadership and team motivation
Sooner or later, a leader will face people who are unmotivated, whether for personal or family reasons or because they are unhappy with the company. In those moments, the leader needs sensitivity and empathy to address the issue without hurting productivity, adding pressure, or putting the person’s well-being at risk.
Time management and prioritization
With so many demands and often lean teams, a leader has to decide what comes first and organize the team’s time as well as possible. Even when people manage their own time, especially in remote work, the leader should act as a compass for day-to-day work.
Adapting to change and innovation
Flexibility is a key soft skill for leaders, because a company goes through different market cycles. In good times, the team may grow, a new office may open, or a product may launch. The leader has to keep up with these changes and adapt, including adopting tools that make the team’s work easier.
Technical knowledge of the field
As mentioned, a leader at a technology company who works with new tools needs to stay current and even suggest new platforms. That is why a tech lead or a CTO, for example, has usually been a developer before stepping away from code to lead.
Ethics and integrity at work
Above all, a leadership skills assessment cannot ignore ethics, honesty, professionalism, and integrity. A company can invest in good pay, benefits, diversity, and marketing, but a leader without ethical principles can undo it all and create a poor experience for the team.
Measure leadership skills with evidence
Situational judgment tests and behavioral assessments show how someone acts when facing real management dilemmas, before they step into the role or while they already hold it.
Tools for a leadership skills assessment
Once the skills are defined, the next step for HR or recruiting is choosing assessment tools that are efficient and produce reliable results. If you need a reference framework, the Executive Core Qualifications used by the U.S. federal government are a solid starting point.
Here are some tools for assessing leaders. Pick the ones that fit your company best:
- 360-degree feedback: gathers input from peers, direct reports, managers, and other stakeholders for a full view of leadership skills.
- Engagement survey: measures, anonymously, how satisfied people are with their leaders.
- Structured interviews: one-on-one conversations to assess competencies, experience, and leadership style.
- Performance reviews: specific, objective metrics to measure progress against goals.
- Behavioral competency assessments: measure skills such as empathy, communication, and conflict resolution.
- Behavioral and skills tests: behavioral assessments and situational judgment tests to measure specific traits and competencies.
- Continuous feedback: a system where leaders get regular input and can adjust how they work.
- Results review: looks at how the leader’s decisions affect metrics such as profitability, customer satisfaction, and employee engagement.
To organize results and compare leaders, many companies use the 9-box grid, which plots performance against potential, together with skills mapping for the whole team.
Related reading
- The 9-Box Grid: What It Is and How to Use It
- Skills Mapping: The Complete Guide for Companies
- Psychometric Tests for Hiring: Types and When to Use Them
- Coodesh assessments: technical, behavioral, and cognitive skills
Conclusion
In short, a leadership skills assessment should match what each company needs. Even so, it almost always covers soft skills tied to the role, such as decision making, ethics, the ability to give feedback, and managing the team’s time.
Assess your current and future leaders
Coodesh lets you run behavioral, situational judgment, and technical assessments for candidates and for leaders already at your company, including engineering teams, so you can build high-performing teams.
Large company or custom needs? Book a demo with our team.


